The Phonics Plus Five Blog

« Did You Know that Lobsters, Birds, Cats and Dogs Can Do Math? | Main | A Recipe for Success? »

Bad Handwriting? If It's Any Comfort, The USA Is Not Alone

When I was a child, several of my older relatives were illiterate (no small factor in my going into the line of work that I chose). And I recall that when they had to write a letter, they went to a "scribe" --one of the more learned people in the neighborhood. There, they would dictate what they had to say and he (it always seemed to be a "he") would put their words on paper. Then the letter would sent on its way.

It's been a long time since I heard the word "scribe" but I came across it recently in a British newspaper, The Independent, which reported that thousands of teenagers need "scribes" to help them write their exams because they are incapable of answering questions in longhand themselves.

To satisfy examiners that a request for a scribe is valid, a candidate must either have a physical disability, a sudden injury or be assessed by a qualified psychologist or specialist teacher. Students are eligible for a scribe if they can prove they cannot write more than 10 words a minute.

The requests occur primarily in subjects which required detailed writing, such as English, history and citizenship. In Scotland, examiners have called for handwriting classes to be reintroduced because so many pupils cannot write longhand.

Experts say speed is not the only factor. More scripts than ever are illegible because the email and text generation are unable to write properly by hand. Examination centers are also considering the use of word processors in more cases – especially for those candidates with known handwriting difficulties.

The situation is not unusual when, as now, major technological changes have disrupted the usual patterns. It may well be that in a few years, students will be allowed to dispense with handwriting and do all their writing on devices such as computers. With Dragon-type speech input, they may not even have to type. All they need do is talk into a microphone and the software will be the rest.

On the other hand, it seems foolish to lose any skill --especially when it is so easy to teach. With proper instruction in the early grades, effective handwriting can be taught --and maintained for life. Unfortunately, under the "drill is kill" mantra, handwriting training was deemed to be tedious and it was discarded. Perhaps the rise of problems such as those noted in The Independent will lead schools to restore --what can so easily be restored.

Comments

Oddly, one of the newest tools for learning to write properly has come from the world of mobile phones.
Here in the USA, an emergency medicine physician named Harvey Castro (owner of the medical software firm Deep Pocket Series) has released an iPhone app called Better Letters -- a multi-featured handwriting course on the iPhone, so doctors can take it anywhere and practice without embarrassment. (As Dr. Castro points out: if it will work on physicians' handwriting, it will work on any handwriting.)

This app is attracting many users -- not only doctors -- and today it reached #132 in the iPhone App Store's list of Top Medical Software.

For more information, see the company's informational page about the app --
http://bit.ly/BetterLetters --
and vist the app's App Store page at http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/better-letters/id335485938?mt=8

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the security code:



Copyright (c) 2007 Darjon Learning, Inc. All rights reserved.
Legal Return Policy Contact Us